Home

What Cast Albums Give That Soundtracks Don't, Part II

You may recall that last week I listed 25 of the best songs that cast albums offer that soundtracks do not – because, more often than not, the film versions dropped these musical gems.

Although there are well more than a hundred that fit that category, I whittled my personal favorites list down to 50 and ranked my bottom 25 according to my own preference -- which, of course, will be different from yours.

Now I’m giving my 25 top selections. How much do we agree – or disagree? Let me know!

My top 25:

25. “The Miller's Son” (A Little Night Music) – Perhaps the perceptions are beyond Petra’s ken, but they’re fascinating to hear.

24. “I Am Ashamed That Women Are So Simple” (Kiss Me, Kate) – What a slap in the face to lyricist Will Shakespeare!

23. “My Own Best Friend” (Chicago) – Maybe Ms. Zellweger couldn’t handle it?

22. “Long before I Knew You” (Bells Are Ringing) – A lovely Jule Styne ballad.

21. “Going Down” (Hair) – Forgive me if I DO cry on losing this one.

20. “Marry the Man Today” (Guys and Dolls) – If only for “Give him your hand today, and save the fist for after.”

19. “I’m a Bad, Bad Man” (Annie Get Your Gun) – But it’s a good, good song.

18. “Motherhood” (Hello, Dolly!) – Great fun, no matter who wrote it.

17. “I Put My Hand In” (Hello, Dolly!) – Much better than the song that replaced it.

16. “Everybody Loves to Take a Bow” (Hazel Flagg/Living It Up) – A great 11 o’clock number.

15. “Liaisons” (A Little Night Music) – And not just because Sondheim rhymed “women” with “indiscrimin-ate.”

14. “I Just Heard” a/k/a “The Rumor” (Fiddler on the Roof) – Hear the ramifications of men and women dancing.

13. “The Music and the Mirror” (A Chorus Line) – Play me the music!

12. “Don’t Tell Mama” (Cabaret)– A new decade is about to start, but Sally is still singing a Charleston from the one that’s just ending.

11. “Moonshine Lullaby” – (Annie Get Your Gun) -- As tender as Merman can get.

10. “I Can Cook, Too” (On the Town) – The sheet music demands it be sung “Hot and fast,” which Nancy Walker certainly observed.

9. “Take Him” (Pal Joey) – Two women officially – if ruefully -- fall out of love with a heel.

8. “Hello Twelve, Hello Thirteen, Hello Love” (A Chorus Line) – Has all of adolescence ever been as expertly captured in one song?

7. “A Bushel and a Peck” (Guys and Dolls) -- Even though the nation knew this song well and considered it a hit.

6. “What Do You Want of Me?” (Man of La Mancha) – A song in which Aldonza genuinely does show her Dulcinean side.

4. “Blow, Gabriel, Blow” (Anything Goes) – Yes, it showed up in the 1956 Anything Goes film, but we really can’t call that drastic rewrite (and rotten picture) a true adaptation of Anything Goes. It’s the first movie version, filmed in 1936, that dropped this one.

3. “I’ve Never Been in Love Before” (Guys and Dolls) – No one could write more masculine-sounding music than Frank Loesser.

2. “Some Other Time” (On the Town) – As all the characters sing, “Oh, well!”

1. “Another Op'nin', Another Show” (Kiss Me, Kate) – The quintessential opening number, and the movie doesn’t use it?

Oh, and let’s end with two Honorable Mentions: “An Old-Fashioned Wedding” (Annie Get Your Gun, 1966 recording) and “The Contract” (Gigi, original cast) – songs not in the film versions, but terrific songs that were written years later.

Peter Filichia also writes Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays at www.theatermania.com

POSTED BYPFILICHIA

Comments for this Site Blog

In the film GUYS AND DOLLS, the tune "A bushel and a Peck", was too short as The Hotbox scene was made longer than it was on stage.

The soundtrack of the film version of SOUTH PACIFIC added a song that wasn't in the original Broadway cast-"My Girl Back Home"- written by Rogers and Hammerstein but not included in the Broadway stage version.